Drive Sweeper
Windows 10 & 11 Buy license · $29.95
Reference

Disk Cleanup vs Storage Sense: What Each One Cleans and When to Use It

Disk Cleanup vs Storage Sense on Windows 10 and 11: what each one removes, which is safer, what neither of them finds, and how to use both well.

Updated 5 minute read The Drive Sweeper team

Disk Cleanup is the classic tool you run by hand: it lists temporary and system file categories, you tick what to remove, and it deletes them once. Storage Sense is the newer feature in Settings that does a similar job automatically on a schedule, and can also clean old files from the Recycle Bin and Downloads and make OneDrive files online-only. For most people the best answer is to use both: let Storage Sense handle routine upkeep and open Disk Cleanup (or the Temporary files page in Settings) occasionally for a deeper system cleanup. Neither of them looks for duplicate files, which is often where the biggest waste sits.

Disk Cleanup and Storage Sense at a glance

Disk CleanupStorage Sense
Where to find itStart > Disk Cleanup, or cleanmgrSettings > System > Storage > Storage Sense
How it runsManually, when you open itAutomatically on a schedule, or on demand
Temporary filesYesYes
Windows Update leftoversYes, via Clean up system filesThrough the Temporary files page in Settings
Recycle BinEmpties it all if tickedRemoves files older than 1, 14, 30 or 60 days
Downloads folderAll of it, if tickedFiles not opened for 1, 14, 30 or 60 days (off by default)
OneDrive filesNoCan make unused files online-only
Restore pointsAll but the most recent, via More OptionsNo
Duplicates and huge filesNoNo
UndoNo, files are deleted permanentlyNo, files are deleted permanently

What Disk Cleanup does well

Disk Cleanup has been part of Windows for decades and is still included in Windows 11, even though Microsoft now points people to the Storage page in Settings. Its strengths are simplicity and a couple of options Settings does not offer.

  1. Open Start, type Disk Cleanup and select the drive.
  2. Click Clean up system files to include Windows Update Cleanup and other system categories.
  3. On the More Options tab, the System Restore and Shadow Copies button removes all restore points except the most recent one, which can free a lot of space on a PC that has been running for years.

Its weaknesses: it does nothing unless you remember to run it, the Windows Update Cleanup step can be very slow, and everything it removes is gone for good. It also has some quirks, such as sizes that do not always match the space actually freed. If it seems stuck, give it time before cancelling.

Running Disk Cleanup on a schedule

Disk Cleanup has no schedule of its own, but it can be automated. In an administrator terminal, run cleanmgr /sageset:1, tick the categories you want and click OK. Windows saves those choices under the number 1. Running cleanmgr /sagerun:1 then cleans the same categories without asking, so you can add that command to Task Scheduler as a monthly task. It works, but it takes more setting up than Storage Sense, and you cannot see what was removed afterwards.

What Storage Sense does well

Storage Sense is designed to stop the problem coming back. Turn it on once and it quietly clears temporary files on the schedule you pick.

  1. Go to Settings > System > Storage > Storage Sense.
  2. Make sure Cleanup of temporary files is ticked.
  3. Turn on Automatic User content cleanup.
  4. Choose Run Storage Sense: every day, every week, every month or during low free disk space.
  5. Set the Recycle Bin, Downloads and OneDrive options to suit you.

The Downloads option deletes files you have not opened within the period you choose, permanently and without asking. Leave it on Never if you ever keep anything important in Downloads.

In Windows 11, the same Storage page also has Temporary files for a one-off manual cleanup, and Cleanup recommendations, which suggests large or unused files, files already synced to the cloud and apps you have not used for a while. Together they cover most of what Disk Cleanup does.

One more difference worth knowing: Storage Sense works on the drive Windows is installed on and on your user content, while Disk Cleanup lets you pick any drive from a list. If a second internal drive is filling up, Disk Cleanup can clear its Recycle Bin and temporary files directly, although on a data drive that is rarely where the space has gone. Duplicates and large files are the usual cause there.

Which is safer?

For system and temporary files, both are safe. They only remove categories Windows knows are disposable. The risk comes from the personal file options:

  • Ticking Downloads in Disk Cleanup or the Temporary files page deletes your whole Downloads folder.
  • Turning on the Downloads timer in Storage Sense deletes files you have not opened recently, even ones you wanted.
  • Emptying the Recycle Bin automatically removes your last chance to recover something deleted by mistake.

Neither tool sends files to the Recycle Bin, and neither has an undo. If you delete something by accident, our guide to recovering files deleted by Disk Cleanup explains your options.

What neither of them finds

Both tools focus on temporary and system files. That typically recovers a few gigabytes. On a well-used PC, the bigger waste is usually elsewhere:

  • Duplicate files, such as the same videos, photos and music saved in several folders or drives.
  • Similar photos, such as resized copies and near-identical burst shots.
  • Huge files you have forgotten about, such as disk images and virtual machines.
  • Old downloads that Storage Sense would only remove with an aggressive, blind timer.

Drive Sweeper covers that gap. It clears the same kind of temporary files and update leftovers, and also finds duplicates by content, similar photos, huge files and downloads you have not opened in months. Each item is labeled safe, review or keep, and you approve everything before it goes. Unlike both built-in tools, Drive Sweeper keeps removed files in a restore area for 30 days.

  1. Turn on Storage Sense with temporary file cleanup and a monthly or low-space schedule. Leave Downloads on Never.
  2. Once every few months, open Disk Cleanup or the Temporary files page and clean system files, including Windows Update Cleanup.
  3. Twice a year, or when space is tight, look for duplicates, huge files and old downloads, which neither built-in tool handles.

For the full process in order, see how to free up disk space on Windows 11, and for a closer look at the temporary file categories themselves, see how to delete temporary files in Windows 11.

Frequently asked questions

Is Disk Cleanup being removed from Windows 11?

Microsoft now points people to Storage settings, but Disk Cleanup is still included in Windows 11. You can open it by searching for Disk Cleanup or running cleanmgr.

Does Storage Sense delete my personal files?

Only from Downloads and the Recycle Bin, and only if you turn those options on. It can also make OneDrive files online-only, which removes the local copy but keeps the file in the cloud.

Can I use Disk Cleanup and Storage Sense together?

Yes. They clean overlapping areas, so running both is safe. Many people let Storage Sense run on a schedule and open Disk Cleanup occasionally for system files.

Get three guides like this every month, plus software update notices.Subscribe →